Harvest Public Media: Vertical farming — towering vision, uncertain future
April 23, 2014
Farmers are making inroads supplying local food to hungry city foodies, but many producers are trying to grow more food in urban centers.
City real estate is at a premium, so some producers are finding more space by using what's called "vertical farming," and going up rather than spreading out.
Growers across the country are heading indoors, using greenhouses and hydroponics — growing plants in a water and nutrient solution instead of soil and using lamps to replace sunlight. Vertical farming takes that to a new level.
But what exactly is a "vertical farm"?
Do an internet search and you'll get some very different pictures of what that term means.
Some conceptualized vertical farms are like space-age skyscrapers, while others are simple, boxy structures with racks of artificially lit plants stacked to the ceiling.
Recommended Stories For You
The man widely credited with bring the term into the mainstream says it's simple: any high-tech greenhouse that goes up rather than out.
"Instead of spreading out," said Columbia University ecologist and professor emeritus Dickson Despommier, "take those greenhouses and stack them on top of each other, employing the same technologies — you've got yourself a vertical farm."
Despommier is among the futurists who argue that the booming global urban population will make self-sustaining urban food systems a necessity.
"I can see the urban landscape parasitizing the rural landscape for its resources," Despommier said, adding that he sees densely populated areas in Europe, Korea and Japan benefitting most from his vertical vision.
But critics of that vision say vertical farming won't be able to produce the scale of food a growing population will need – at least not without massive amounts of energy and other inputs.
"Vertical farming is kind of a vision of factory farming of plants," said Stan Cox of The Land Institute in Kansas, a group that advocates for environmental and sustainable agriculture issues. "Just like with animals, it requires much higher inputs of energy, much more stress on the plant, and generally is doing things the hard way."
In Chicago, entrepreneur John Edel is working hard to show skeptics that garbage itself can fuel vertical farming, making it more sustainable. With a grant from the State of Illinois, he's installing a giant anaerobic digester that will convert truckloads of food waste into biogas, burned onsite to keep the lights on.
"We're in the thick of construction now," Edel said. "I think by the end of this year everything will be operational and we'll be well beyond net-zero."
Edel's vertical farm, The Plant Chicago, looks different than the architectural renderings of towering green skyscrapers you'll find on the web.
In 2010, Edel bought a four-story, 94,000 square foot warehouse in a bankruptcy sale. The hulking red brick facility, built in the 1920s next to Chicago's Union Stockyards, used to process bacon and ham. Now it is home to 11 small-scale food businesses, from bakers to kombucha brewers to aquaponic farms growing greens and fish for area restaurants.
"To create those jobs and to grow the food as locally as possible," Edel said. "In order to reduce the pollution associated with its transport, the costs associated with its transport, and to keep those dollars here, close to home."
Edel's operation, which he calls a "social enterprise", is trying to create a replicable model of closed-loop, energy-independent urban food production. He's less concerned about competing for space in a grocery store produce aisle than he is about raising awareness.
But FarmedHere, a commercial vertical farm in Chicago, sells basil and other greens to upscale grocery chains throughout the city and suburbs. And Green Spirit Farms recently inked a deal to expand its vertical farming operation to an empty factory near Scranton, Pa. At 300,000 square feet, it would become the largest in the nation.
The move to grow more food indoors has also caught on for pharmaceuticals. The Defense Department funded a vertical farm in Texas that grows plants for vaccines and cancer-fighting drugs.
Still, most vertical farming operations today, even with increased efficiency due to LED lighting, have a hefty electric bill and carbon footprint.
Farms aren't all white picket fences and red barns anymore.
And in the future, they might be in skyscrapers. ❖
Peter Gray, based at WUIS in Springfield, Ill., reports for Harvest Public Media, a reporting collaboration of WUIS and other public media stations in the Midwest. Harvest covers issues related to food and food production. For more, go to HarvestPublicMedia.org.